Old Newgate Road by Keith Scribner

Old Newgate Road

Keith Scribner

Moving, insightful, and suspenseful, Old Newgate Road is a masterful portrait of a haunted family and successive generations of men struggling against all odds and often violent impulses to truly know one another and their loved ones.

Start Reading….

Read Excerpt Now


Sign me up to receive news about Keith Scribner.

Place our blog button on your blog to let people know you are a member of this great program!

From the author of The Oregon Experiment, the story of a father's return to his childhood home, the site of unspeakable tragedy, and of the complex and often warring obligations--not least forgiveness--we have to our family, our friends, and our past.

Old Newgate Road runs through the tobacco fields of northern Connecticut that once drove the local economy. It's where Cole Callahan spent his youth, in a historic white colonial that his family was devoted to restoring--painstakingly, relentlessly, pointlessly. But the famous claim that you can't go home again falls far short in this instance. Cole has not come back to this house, to this street, in thirty years--not since he was a teenager, when one night his father murdered his mother in a fit of rage. Now, however, he finally dares to risk it, ostensibly to collect precious material for his construction business on the west coast, and is shocked to discover his elderly father, freed from prison, living alone in their old home, and succumbing to dementia. Compelled by a sense of responsibility to a man he hates, and confronted in middle age by everything he'd left unfinished when he fled this place in his aborted childhood, he finds that the time for a reckoning has at last come.

Matters grow even more complicated when his estranged wife calls to say their ultra-progressive, rabble-rousing son has run up against the law and been expelled from high school. And so Cole summons Daniel to East Granby to work in the tobacco fields--his own job growing up--and soon their lives are enmeshed with the family legacy, and with Cole's boyhood sweetheart as well as his nemesis. What unfolds over this summer surprises and challenges them all, as they contend with the sinister history they share and desperately try to invent a future that isn't doomed by it.

Moving, insightful, and suspenseful, Old Newgate Road is a masterful portrait of a haunted family and successive generations of men struggling against all odds and often violent impulses to truly know one another and their loved ones, and to somehow come to terms with themselves.

Advance Galley Reviews

The synopsis was more interesting than the actual book for me, unfortunately. I definitely wanted to like it more than I did but it unfortunately fell a bit flat for me. 3 stars.

Nevet got a chance to read this title due to 2 prior arc reads. I wish I spent less time on them and gave this one a chance.

I wanted to like this book. The blurb was so intriguing. What should have been an easy, enjoyable read – it was only 312 pages - turned into a slumbering, tough-to-get-through exercise. Maybe it was because the main character was seeking to forgive his father for an unforgivable act. Maybe it was because the author totally abandoned two of the book’s first main support characters for no obvious reason. Maybe it was because I kept thinking to myself “get some help” so very often. This book had so much potential but I feel like many key moments were either glossed over too quickly or not fully fleshed out. This easily could have been a 500-page book with real deep characters, interactions and a message. Instead, it felt rushed and forced. The back and forth from past to present gave the book an interesting progression but there were many doors that were opened that were never closed or revisited. I received an electronic version of this book from www.firsttoread.com in exchange for an honest review. This review is also posted to www.goodreads.com


3.5 stars Thank you to Penguin's First to Read and Knopf Publishing Group for allowing me to read and review this ARC. Published Jan 8, 2019 This is one of the better novels I have read that relates to men. A story of three generations, son, father and grandfather, all different. But all still trying to move through the guilt of the past. Although I thought that this book started off a bit slow, it took no time to become involved in the lives of these three men. Phil, the grandfather, released from prison, squatting at the old homestead and trying to fight off Alzheimers. Cole, the main character, home to help his father and try to rebuild the old colonial house. And Daniel, sent to this tobacco producing farmland for the summer, to keep him out of trouble. Each one as different as night and day, yet bound together by stories from the past. This is my first book by Keith Scribner. It was a good introduction to an author that I intend to read again. His story was easy to read, kept me involved, and showed the comparisons and contrasts between not only generations from the same family, but also with other families of men from that same time frame and geographical area, detailing how our past can predict our future, but also direct our dreams.

Wanted very much to read, but due to illness was not able to complete before expiration.

Thank you FTR and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an hosnest review. This book is fast paced, a thriller, and yet with family and love woven in the story. How do you forgive the unforgivable? Cole Callahan has witnessed violence while at home as a child. When he returns to his hometown years later, he sees his father inhabiting their abandoned old house, in a state of dementia. How does Cole move forward, caring for his father while holding on to his past, is at the center of this book. His present, his marriage and his child, is also marred by his past experiences. His present and past intertwine to create good story. While better writing could have uplifted the book, the story itself has good angles and plot turns to keep it interesting. 3.5 stars.

Hard to put down. Complex and intriguing characters. Three generations of men finding their way. Compelling relationship between father and son from 2 different eras. Moving at times as the characters move through their feelings and issues. 4 stars

This book drew my interest due to the setting. Growing up in a Connecticut, I am familiar with the tobacco fields and even spent one summer working on a tobacco farm. The author was accurate in the portrayal and really brought them back to life for me. The plot line was filled with emotionally charged scenes that we’re compelling. I would recommend this book to others. Thanks for the opportunity to read it in advance.

Not the best book I've read but not the worst either. Story moved along just fine and at a good pace.

I received this book from First to Read for an honest review. This book is about Cole Callahan and his family in Connecticut and also in Portland, Oregon. Cole grows up in Connecticut, East Granby area, working tobacco (I did not know they ever grew tobacco in Connecticut so this was interesting to me) and in the midst of domestic violence he witnesses between his parents. Years later, Cole comes back to his hometown to buy some lumber for a renovation and discovers his father, suffering from dementia and living in the family home. Cole's son gets in trouble in Portland and so he brings his son to Connecticut for the summer to get him away from his troubles there. What Cole discovers while staying with his father and trying to get help for him because he needs constant care makes for a very good read. The story of the Callahan was riveting to me. I felt like I was right there throughout the whole book. The characters were really well-developed and the editing was good. I really enjoyed this book and had a hard time putting it down. Will have to look and see if this author has any more books because I really enjoyed this one.

Cole Callahan grew up in Connecticut, working summers in the tobacco fields and spending every spare minute with his girlfriend, Liz. It sounds like your typical and idyllic high school existence, except for one difference; his parents fight constantly and in one final fight his father kills Cole’s mother. Fast forward to current day. Cole is living on the West Coast and separated from his wife. An architect and builder, he’s returned to Connecticut and his hometown to pick up some lumber for a renovation. In doing so, he also returns to his past, meeting up with his former girlfriend, her brother, the town bully, and his father, showing signs of dementia, who’s been released from prison and is living in their former home. Thrown into the mix is Daniel, Cole’s son, who’s been suspended from school and joins his father, who hopes to reach him in some way. Could there be a bigger recipe for disaster? While there are disasters in Old Newgate Road, there are successes and for me the best is when Cole reflects on forgiveness and determines that “...forgiveness doesn’t happen in an instant – it’s not a simple decision, but an accumulation of generous acts, of kindness and taking care. He’s stayed on because this summer is what forgiveness looks like.” It takes a while for Cole to reach this epiphany, but he does and it’s worth the wait. Old Newgate Road is a good book and I’d recommend it.

I found this to be a transformative and compelling read. I felt that I could almost smell the tobacco fields at time. The relationship between Cole and his Dad was bittersweet as he came to terms with his father's dementia. Cole and Daniel's relationship was able to grow throughout the book and it was good to see how they really were not that different. I would really enjoy reading more from this author. Thanks for the ARC, First to Read.

I found this well written and a fascinating emotional journey. Sometimes I had to put it down, to give myself a break from the intense emotions. The trauma and conflict were so well portrayed that I couldn't help share the characters' feelings. That being said, the ending was a little bit of a let down. It seemed to jump to the final resolution quickly. With such a great explanation of the amount of work it took to get past the initial trauma, the trip to the final resolution was presented as a fait accompli, with no work required. That aside, it was overall an excellent novel.

What can I say about this particularly novel but that it is a serviceable piece of fiction. Nothing that really lodges firmly in your brain for later mulling, OLD NEWGATE ROAD is not unlike a well-constructed building that is short on architectural embellishments. Cole Callahan is a typical middle-aged protagonist looking back on a traumatic past as he tries to come to grips with it all. He revisits the old homestead in search of barn wood for his contracting business, and thus we begin a trip down memory lane that gets a bit muddled with all the tense changes that aren't entirely consistent. I didn't regret finishing the book, but there were passages that I skimmed to speed things up. In essence, OLD NEWGATE ROAD is fine to pick up but if you've other, more enthralling, books on hand, shift this one to the bottom of the TBR pile.


More to Explore

  • The Oregon Experiment

Copy the following link